{
  "schema_version": "study7-index-downloads-2",
  "staging_only": false,
  "original_contract_sha256": "8c8cd11d528bf42ae7e1ca0b12e0451f293b88e8d97b263c038c4768ec9e3e65",
  "original_contract_newline": "LF",
  "original_contract_key_order": [
    "schema_version",
    "publication",
    "study",
    "source",
    "population",
    "categories",
    "metadata_revision"
  ],
  "metadata": {
    "schema_version": "study7-index-2",
    "publication": {
      "state": "ready_for_deposit",
      "gate_ready": true,
      "gate_checked_utc": "2026-10-09T23:31:38.094198+00:00",
      "gate_error_count": 0,
      "gate_blockers": [],
      "verified_criteria": 0
    },
    "study": {
      "doi": "10.5281/zenodo.23271935",
      "url": "https://broadcastwell.com/research/ai-written-rfp",
      "title": "The AI written RFP",
      "byline": "Prepared by the Broadcastwell team",
      "license": {
        "name": "CC BY 4.0",
        "url": "https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/"
      },
      "dispute": "Any named company may request one no-cost re-run at index@broadcastwell.com; both results are published.",
      "review_status": "Team review: in progress",
      "review_note": "Semantic coding and dated page comparisons follow the published rules. Independent analyst review remains in progress.",
      "product": {
        "name": "Checklist Audit",
        "price_usd": 490,
        "url": "https://broadcastwell.com/buyers-checklist"
      },
      "method": {
        "version": "1.1",
        "statement": "Every figure comes from the published method, v1.1.",
        "url": "https://broadcastwell.com/methodology"
      },
      "limits": "Observed source answer frequencies. Wilson intervals describe the calculation, not independent population inference. Repeated runs are not independent performance tests. Page comparisons cover only the dated page and stated scope. An unstated claim is not an absent product feature.",
      "median_definition": "Each vendor figure uses the median across the five most named vendors in the frozen category release, including zero counts. Adjacency compares distinct source answers for the same criterion; page coverage compares criteria for the same page state. Medians are descriptive and have no confidence interval."
    },
    "source": {
      "doi": "10.5281/zenodo.22907695",
      "capture_dates": [
        "2026-09-22",
        "2026-09-23"
      ],
      "engines": [
        "ChatGPT",
        "Claude",
        "Perplexity",
        "Google AI Overviews",
        "Google AI Mode"
      ],
      "answers_asset": {
        "url": "https://zenodo.org/api/records/22907695/files/answers-2026-09.jsonl/content",
        "sha256": "221c94e1ebad2bc87d7cd20837fa670cc40b10dba6f68b75423dc8bee69697b3"
      },
      "release_asset": {
        "url": "https://zenodo.org/api/records/22907695/files/release-2026-09.json/content",
        "sha256": "e7829183f6785357787fcf85d3c27999403b0a329f349dad4c7343b11d23f142"
      },
      "offset_unit": "Unicode code points",
      "hash_encoding": "UTF8",
      "record_id_rule": "category_id + | + question_id + | + engine + | + repeat_index",
      "perplexity_note": "Perplexity quotations are omitted. Exact original record IDs, offsets and hashes resolve to the deposited source answers."
    },
    "population": {
      "scheduled_answers": 2100,
      "original_exclusions": 5,
      "eligible_inputs": 2095,
      "derived_exclusions": 2,
      "answer_base": 2093,
      "exclusions": [
        {
          "category_id": "construction-project-management",
          "record_id": "construction-project-management|q7|Google AI Mode|3",
          "stage": "study",
          "reason": "Raw text is a request-limit response, not an observed buyer answer. Original Index release bytes and validity field are retained unchanged.",
          "reason_display": "Raw text is a request limit response, not an observed buyer answer. Original Index release bytes and validity field are retained unchanged."
        },
        {
          "category_id": "dental-practice-management",
          "record_id": "dental-practice-management|q2|Google AI Overviews|2",
          "stage": "original",
          "reason": "no AI Overview returned for this query",
          "reason_display": "no AI Overview returned for this query"
        },
        {
          "category_id": "hotel-property-management",
          "record_id": "hotel-property-management|q10|Google AI Overviews|1",
          "stage": "original",
          "reason": "no AI Overview returned for this query",
          "reason_display": "no AI Overview returned for this query"
        },
        {
          "category_id": "radiology-medical-imaging",
          "record_id": "radiology-medical-imaging|q1|Google AI Overviews|2",
          "stage": "study",
          "reason": "Off-topic answer about imaging-table pads, not PACS software. Preserved unchanged in the Index raw file; excluded only from this derived study base.",
          "reason_display": "Off topic answer about imaging table pads, not PACS software. Preserved unchanged in the Index raw file; excluded only from this derived study base."
        },
        {
          "category_id": "residential-property-management",
          "record_id": "residential-property-management|q7|Google AI Overviews|3",
          "stage": "original",
          "reason": "no AI Overview returned for this query",
          "reason_display": "no AI Overview returned for this query"
        },
        {
          "category_id": "residential-property-management",
          "record_id": "residential-property-management|q9|Google AI Overviews|1",
          "stage": "original",
          "reason": "no AI Overview returned for this query",
          "reason_display": "no AI Overview returned for this query"
        },
        {
          "category_id": "veterinary-practice-management",
          "record_id": "veterinary-practice-management|q2|Google AI Overviews|2",
          "stage": "original",
          "reason": "We couldn't get valid results for this search. Please try again later.",
          "reason_display": "We couldn't get valid results for this search. Please try again later."
        }
      ]
    },
    "metadata_revision": {
      "kind": "study_doi_added",
      "baseline_contract_sha256": "0f5d4402c3e847868a85fad7ded95e559274ec54930bb1de856e029af65558a9",
      "baseline_integrity_manifest_sha256": "ed97459da3a726a9587da5d71b2fe4e4899eeb62f587619dca8174164ddc6279",
      "study_version_doi": "10.5281/zenodo.23271935",
      "study_concept_doi": "10.5281/zenodo.23271934",
      "research_observations_unchanged": true
    }
  },
  "categories": [
    {
      "id": "construction-project-management",
      "name": "Construction project management software",
      "category_slug": "construction-project-management",
      "path": "categories/construction-project-management.json",
      "sha256": "b143680377fd6472d32fd820cbfa25458cc368894382bbc2715949f26d4d8225",
      "bytes": 2697167,
      "answer_base": 149,
      "criteria": 92,
      "evidence_spans": 425,
      "adjacency_spans": 59,
      "page_comparisons": 460
    },
    {
      "id": "dealership-management-systems",
      "name": "Dealership management systems",
      "category_slug": "dealership-management-systems",
      "path": "categories/dealership-management-systems.json",
      "sha256": "9e3d6bab7ffbefe77f16fbfd74855a8e4a96059d8d6a56e3cb9ba2a56434c7c5",
      "bytes": 4709365,
      "answer_base": 150,
      "criteria": 159,
      "evidence_spans": 736,
      "adjacency_spans": 62,
      "page_comparisons": 795
    },
    {
      "id": "dental-practice-management",
      "name": "Dental practice management software",
      "category_slug": "dental-practice-management",
      "path": "categories/dental-practice-management.json",
      "sha256": "59af46111488b8b4d9c7222100f5f64cc86c25c5372e37784c15759da1194183",
      "bytes": 4871572,
      "answer_base": 149,
      "criteria": 155,
      "evidence_spans": 775,
      "adjacency_spans": 155,
      "page_comparisons": 775
    },
    {
      "id": "field-service-management",
      "name": "Field service management software",
      "category_slug": "field-service-management",
      "path": "categories/field-service-management.json",
      "sha256": "fa70aa0db398c839f46596f28d2599360a49de63b7a69317b0ecfea1e85bc2cc",
      "bytes": 3520823,
      "answer_base": 150,
      "criteria": 120,
      "evidence_spans": 714,
      "adjacency_spans": 82,
      "page_comparisons": 600
    },
    {
      "id": "hotel-property-management",
      "name": "Hotel property management software",
      "category_slug": "hotel-property-management",
      "path": "categories/hotel-property-management.json",
      "sha256": "fa40fb32b8dd2de76c564ed8a84fd805d18f0c5fd54b62247f1723a5e04b07d1",
      "bytes": 4232385,
      "answer_base": 149,
      "criteria": 131,
      "evidence_spans": 802,
      "adjacency_spans": 216,
      "page_comparisons": 655
    },
    {
      "id": "insurance-agency-management",
      "name": "Insurance agency management systems",
      "category_slug": "insurance-agency-management",
      "path": "categories/insurance-agency-management.json",
      "sha256": "58b0931766de52b900133906024b5e31233a6d5530d290845dd803a09544d7ce",
      "bytes": 4928877,
      "answer_base": 150,
      "criteria": 169,
      "evidence_spans": 647,
      "adjacency_spans": 137,
      "page_comparisons": 845
    },
    {
      "id": "legal-practice-management",
      "name": "Legal practice management software",
      "category_slug": "legal-practice-management",
      "path": "categories/legal-practice-management.json",
      "sha256": "a2277719e2b2ff6cda19668a842de46efcc1a55b58f23a487fe4bbc5a18bafd4",
      "bytes": 4164050,
      "answer_base": 150,
      "criteria": 126,
      "evidence_spans": 950,
      "adjacency_spans": 106,
      "page_comparisons": 630
    },
    {
      "id": "loan-origination-software",
      "name": "Loan origination and lending software",
      "category_slug": "loan-origination-software",
      "path": "categories/loan-origination-software.json",
      "sha256": "66111f7227c8dbb58bffb0919ab5b103c56afc157e87007a5e6059d82929c451",
      "bytes": 6020473,
      "answer_base": 150,
      "criteria": 197,
      "evidence_spans": 762,
      "adjacency_spans": 188,
      "page_comparisons": 985
    },
    {
      "id": "radiology-medical-imaging",
      "name": "Radiology and medical imaging software",
      "category_slug": "radiology-medical-imaging",
      "path": "categories/radiology-medical-imaging.json",
      "sha256": "7f1b02d3a735cd112481cc919531d541d78ac8aec8e89f36c8e18a960e5c496e",
      "bytes": 4645700,
      "answer_base": 149,
      "criteria": 156,
      "evidence_spans": 705,
      "adjacency_spans": 202,
      "page_comparisons": 780
    },
    {
      "id": "residential-property-management",
      "name": "Residential property management software",
      "category_slug": "residential-property-management",
      "path": "categories/residential-property-management.json",
      "sha256": "4b853c8751438b3c222e3bc68d263b527bfb301a51c1feb5f2d3518487b525c1",
      "bytes": 4458434,
      "answer_base": 148,
      "criteria": 151,
      "evidence_spans": 760,
      "adjacency_spans": 157,
      "page_comparisons": 755
    },
    {
      "id": "transportation-management-systems",
      "name": "Transportation management systems",
      "category_slug": "transportation-management-systems",
      "path": "categories/transportation-management-systems.json",
      "sha256": "0e952517675d5e180b35ff78a83a3f0f276365261f3591e0882880583b4a04f1",
      "bytes": 4766081,
      "answer_base": 150,
      "criteria": 150,
      "evidence_spans": 720,
      "adjacency_spans": 195,
      "page_comparisons": 750
    },
    {
      "id": "veterinary-practice-management",
      "name": "Veterinary practice management software",
      "category_slug": "veterinary-practice-management",
      "path": "categories/veterinary-practice-management.json",
      "sha256": "db70bf975ae3be627bf8fea819f729029c2763da9d7c8a73eaef9f80c9ba2e6e",
      "bytes": 4407482,
      "answer_base": 149,
      "criteria": 141,
      "evidence_spans": 782,
      "adjacency_spans": 135,
      "page_comparisons": 705
    },
    {
      "id": "crm",
      "name": "CRM",
      "category_slug": "crm",
      "path": "categories/crm.json",
      "sha256": "1bf8b4fda11d0833d8e2496bbe273887ae1c4397bdfd35e6deb8675761bedf84",
      "bytes": 4744783,
      "answer_base": 150,
      "criteria": 119,
      "evidence_spans": 1027,
      "adjacency_spans": 369,
      "page_comparisons": 595
    },
    {
      "id": "project_management",
      "name": "Project management",
      "category_slug": "project-management",
      "path": "categories/project-management.json",
      "sha256": "e7736551deb6efd18619f3f59f431d2da62f528c46325e2439a3dc9115d8ad50",
      "bytes": 4738022,
      "answer_base": 150,
      "criteria": 137,
      "evidence_spans": 742,
      "adjacency_spans": 354,
      "page_comparisons": 685
    }
  ]
}